Ocean Bay Park Homes for Rent

    Email us at rentals@fisr.com with your budget, dates and criteria, and we will get back to you with a list of homes that meet your needs!

    Ocean Bay Park lies between Seaview and Point O Woods. If Ocean Beach is the Manhattan of Fire Island and Seaview is its tony suburbs, Ocean Bay Park is its Brooklyn. Known for its relaxed and laid back environment, the community prides itself on its freedom from the restrictions, village taxes and homeowners association dues that come with the territory in neighboring communities. Formerly a haven for sharehouses and the occasional raucous party, Ocean Bay Park has been undergoing a radical transformation in recent years. Much like in gentrifying Brooklyn, families are buying up beat up bungalows and pouring capital into renovations and new home builds everywhere you look. Ocean Bay Park is also particularly attractive to buyers of investment properties because the areas low taxes keep carrying costs down. Additionally, Ocean Bay Park is subject to the Town of Brookhaven zoning code which is more permissive than the neighboring township of Islips rules. The standard lot size in Ocean Bay Park is 50 X 100.

    Direct ferry service from Bay Shore lands you in the heart of the Ocean Bay Park commercial district, which gives off a bohemian and breezy vibe. In town, experience bay front dining at Schooners and Flynns, a pizza parlor, ice cream shop, bagel store & deli, grocery store, and a bicycle rental shop. Head down Cayuga Street towards the beach and youre at the Fire Island Hotel, where you can grab a bite to eat at Hurricanes Bar & Grill or hang out by the pool. Relaxation is paramount in Ocean Bay Park, so make sure you hit the beach. Head over for the 4th of July to enjoy the Fire Department sponsored BBQ or the third week of August to experience the annual Gourmet Fair, which showcases food from local businesses and homeowners. Whether you are looking to buy, rent or day trip, Ocean Bay Park welcomes all!

    to
     
     
     
    Search Search
    •  
    Search

    33  properties match your search;

    Save Search
    Showing 1 - 10 of 33 results| view:  results per page« 1|2|3|4 »
    • Ocean Bay Park, NY
      $3,000 - $6,500
      3 Bedrooms 1 Full Bath 1 Half Bath
      Single Family For Rent ID# OBP-4r
      This 3 bedroom, 1.5 bathroom home has it all! Great location near the Seaview border. Sunny west facing deck. Designer kitchen with Miele and Subzero appliances. Open layout great for family gatherings. Both bathrooms are nicely renovated. Available for monthly or 2 week increments.
      Call Today: 631-988-0819, 631-583-8898, or  Email: Alyssa O'Keefe
      Call Today: or  Email: Fire Island Rentals
    • Ocean Bay Park, NY
      $4,500
      4 Bedrooms 1 Full Bath 1 Half Bath
      Single Family For Rent ID# obp-10
      Welcome to your dream beach getaway in the heart of Ocean Bay Park! This classic Fire Island beach home is the perfect destination for families and friends seeking a relaxing and unforgettable coastal experience. With 4 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, and an open-concept design, this home provides a spacious and comfortable retreat just steps away from the pristine shores of Fire Island.
      Call Today: 631-583-8898, 516-521-6842, or  Email: Joan Woletsky
      Call Today: or  Email: Fire Island Rentals
    • Ocean Bay Park, NY
      $5,000
      3 Bedrooms 2 Full Baths
      Single Family For Rent ID# obp-31r
      3 bedroom 2 bath home located in the heart of Ocean Bay Park. Very close to the beach, this spacious and open concept floor plan is a great place to spend your Fire Island vacation. <br> <br>
      Call Today: 631-583-8898, 516-521-6842, or  Email: Joan Woletsky
      Call Today: or  Email: Fire Island Rentals
    • Ocean Bay Park, NY
      $6,000
      2 Bedrooms 1 Full Bath 1 Half Bath
      Single Family For Rent ID# obp-29r
      Meticulously cared for summer home just steps (3rd house) from the beach being rented for the first time with everything NEW! Prime Location short walk to town of Ocean Beach and situated right on the Seaview/OBP border with entrances in both towns. Open concept layout with fully stocked kitchen, high ceilings with plenty of natural light and ductless AC units in every room. Tastefully updated full bath. Spacious, sunny deck with grill, large outdoor shower complete with powder room, plenty of outdoor space. Storage shed with beach chairs and umbrella. Two brand new Bikes provided. Wifi, streaming for tv. This house named “Easy Does It” is the perfect beach getaway! <BR><BR> Bedroom Configuration:<BR> Bedroom 1: Queen <BR> Bedroom 2: 2 twin beds <BR> \Bedroom 3: Queen (high end extremely comfortable pull out couch from Bloomingdale’s-brand is American leather
      Call Today: 631-583-8898, 516-521-6842, or  Email: Joan Woletsky
      Call Today: or  Email: Fire Island Rentals
    • Ocean Bay Park, NY
      $6,000
      3 Bedrooms 2 Full Baths
      Single Family For Rent ID# obp-20r
      3 Bedrooms that sleeps 9 people with 2 full baths. Well maintained, neat and clean with updated amenities! Open concept living/kitchen/dining with bar eating area and dining table that seats 6. Two large sliding doors open to spacious private deck with BBQ, Outdoor shower, dining and lounges. Bikes, Beach chairs, Beach Towels and bedding provided, bath towels are not provided. Bedroom breakdown is as follows: <br> Master bedroom with King Bed, A/C and full bath <br> Queen bedroom with A/C <br> Bunk room with Twin over Full and Twin over Twin to sleep 5 (2 Adults or 5 kids) with A/C
      Call Today: 631-583-8898, 516-521-6842, or  Email: Joan Woletsky
      Call Today: or  Email: Fire Island Rentals
    • Ocean Bay Park, NY
      $6,000 - $10,000
      5 Bedrooms 3 Full Baths
      Single Family For Rent ID# OBP-17r
      Nicely Updated 5 Bedroom 3 Bathroom 2 Story Home. Beautiful Hardwood Floors With 4 Spacious Bedrooms and 2 Full Bathrooms Downstairs. Open Concept Living/Dining/Kitchen Layout On Second Floor. A Secluded Master Ensuite Upstairs. Large Wrap Around Deck Perfect For Outdoor Entertaining. Pack Your Bags For The Ultimate Beach Retreat!
      Call Today: 631-988-0819, 631-583-8898, or  Email: Alyssa O'Keefe
      Call Today: or  Email: Fire Island Rentals
    • Ocean Bay Park, NY 11770
      $7,000
      $6,500
      3 Bedrooms 1 Full Bath 1 Half Bath
      Single Family For Rent PRICE REDUCED ID# OBP-15r
      Spend your summer vacation at this one level 3 bedroom, 1.5 bathroom home in the heart of laidback Ocean Bay Park! Spacious & comfortable living area with Smart TV perfect for lounging inside. Kitchen located off of living area with direct access to deck with grill and outdoor dining area. Two bedrooms and full bathroom with standup shower on north side of house. Situated off of the living room is third bedroom with private half bathroom and deck access. Back deck offers additional outdoor space for lounging in the sun plus private outdoor shower and shed with laundry & storage for beach chairs, umbrellas & bikes. Easy 4 minute walk down to the beach. Ocean Bay Park ferry & downtown area with restaurants, pizza & ice cream 5 minutes away. Take a 20 minute stroll or 10 minute bike ride over to Ocean Beach for more dining, shopping & entertainment. Pets considered with an additional fee. <br> <br> Bedroom Configuration: <br> Bedroom 1: King <br> Bedroom 2: Twin over Queen Bunk <br> Bedroom 3: Twin over Queen Bunk <br> <br> Available for weekly rent Monday - Sunday <br> July 1-7: $7,000 <br> July & August Weeks: $6,500 <br> August 26-Sept 2: $7,000 <br> <br> *Temporary Photos; Undergoing Renovations to be Completed for Summer 2024!*
      Call Today: 631-988-0819, 631-583-8898, or  Email: Alyssa O'Keefe
      Call Today: or  Email: Fire Island Rentals
    • Ocean Bay Park, NY
      $6,500 - $45,000
      4 Bedrooms 1 Full Bath 1 Half Bath
      Single Family For Rent ID# OBP-11R
      4 bedroom 1.5 bathroom ranch style house with high ceilings, skylights and large open living room, dining area and fully equipped kitchen. House is set far back from street with long ramp leading to the outdoor shower, house, and very large back deck. All new appliances, A/C, ceiling fans and heat. Available to for the season, monthly, or weekly.
      Call Today: 631-583-8898, 516-521-6842, or  Email: Joan Woletsky
      Call Today: or  Email: Fire Island Rentals
    • Ocean Bay Park, NY
      $7,000
      4 Bedrooms 2 Full Baths 1 Half Bath
      Single Family For Rent ID# OBP-19
      Contemporary and pristine 4 bedroom, 2.5 bath monthly rental featuring a lovely back deck and gardens. Available first 2 weeks of August
      Call Today: 631-583-8898, 516-521-6842, or  Email: Joan Woletsky
      Call Today: or  Email: Fire Island Rentals
    • Ocean Bay Park, NY
      $7,500
      5 Bedrooms 1 Full Bath 2 Half Baths
      Single Family For Rent ID# obp-27r
      Fifth house from the beach, near the ferry, restaurants and bay on a lovely quiet street. Very spacious and bright living room with large dining table; new eat-in kitchen with breakfast bar and additional table; four bedrooms and one and a half bathrooms. Lovely deck with couches, dining seating, and outdoor shower. <br> There is also a studio cottage that includes a queen size bed, galley kitchen, and half bathroom. <br> Bedroom breakdown is as follows: <br> Bedroom 1: one queen and one twin <br> Bedroom 2: one double bed <br> Bedroom 3: two twin beds <br> Bedroom 4: two twin beds
      Call Today: 631-988-0819, 631-583-8898, or  Email: Alyssa O'Keefe
      Call Today: or  Email: Fire Island Rentals
    Showing 1 - 10 of 33 results| view:  results per page« 1|2|3|4 »
    FireIsland

    Questions? Just Ask!

      Submit