Alyssa O'Keefe

Alyssa O'Keefe

Licensed Real Estate Salesperson

Cell: 631-988-0819 Office: 631-583-8898

About Alyssa O'Keefe

A Long Island native, Alyssa O'Keefe has been a frequent Fire Island goer for many years. After graduating from SUNY New Paltz in 2013 with a bachelor’s degree in Marketing, Alyssa began building her career in marketing for sports & entertainment events.  After 5 years in the marketing industry, Alyssa decided to apply her marketing and promotion skills to the real estate industry.

Growing up around the construction industry, real estate had always been of interest to her.  Having spent many summer vacations on Fire Island, when the opportunity to join Fire Island Real Estate arose, Alyssa jumped at the chance to pursue her real estate career in such a beautiful and unique place. After specializing in rentals for two years, Alyssa has evolved into a strong sales agent.  With her extensive knowledge of the vacation rental market on Fire Island, Alyssa is an asset to those looking to purchase a rental investment property.  Alyssa is at your service to help you find the perfect home to produce top dollar on your investment or in purchasing your personal beach house retreat!



QUESTIONS? JUST ASK!
Showing 11 - 20 of 63 results| view:  results per page« 1|2|3|4|5|...|last »
  • Ocean Beach, NY 11770
    $13,500
    4 Bedrooms 3 Full Baths 1 Half Bath
    Single Family For Rent ID# OB-47r
    Everything you need to enjoy life at the beach at this new construction 4 bedroom, 3.5 bathroom home in the heart of Ocean Beach! Relax on the deck with sun-drenched pool, outdoor shower, loungers, & outdoor shower. Powder room and laundry room are conveniently located right past the front door. First floor's open layout has luxury kitchen and breakfast bar, dining area and spacious living area with fireplace. First floor spacious primary suite has king size bed and private ensuite. Upstairs are two additional guest bedrooms, full bathroom and second primary suite with private en-suite & private balcony. Only a 2 minute walk to the beach or 4 minute walk into the Village of Ocean Beach for dining, shopping, entertainment & ferry!
  • Ocean Beach, NY
    $12,500
    4 Bedrooms 2 Full Baths
    Single Family For Rent ID# ob-603r
    Fully renovated 4 bedroom home in the heart of OBl! . Fabulous skylit living room with vaulted ceilings and huge slider to the deck. This home features a spacious master bedroom with completely renovated private en-suite bathroom and direct access to the deck, as well as 3 additional bedrooms and another beautifully renovated full bathroom The light and bright eat in kitchen flows out to the deck with a beautiful gazebo for shaded outdoor dining. Getting pool installed with new mahogany deck.
  • Ocean Bay Park, NY
    $12,500
    4 Bedrooms 2 Full Baths
    Single Family For Rent ID# OBP-5r
    Located right on the Bay in Ocean Bay Park, this house was completely renovated in 2023 from top to bottom, inside & out! This home provides all you need to enjoy your stay on Fire Island! Spacious deck allows for plenty of outdoor entertaining, dining and sunbathing with epic bay views. You can easily spend the whole day here with your own private beach area below complete with outdoor shower, chaises, kayaks and more! Stay cool & comfortable with ductless AC throughout. <br>
  • Ocean Beach, NY
    $12,500
    4 Bedrooms 2 Full Baths 1 Half Bath
    Single Family For Rent ID# OB-207R
    This gorgeous house has an amazing second story deck. This upside down house has a beautiful open concept living, dining, and kitchen area.
  • Ocean Beach, NY 11770
    $12,000
    4 Bedrooms 2 Full Baths Sq. Ft. 1464.00:# SqFt
    Single Family For Rent ID# OB-372r
    Brand new 9 X 16 Saltwater Heated Pool! <br> This updated 4 bedroom 2 bathroom home has everything you need to enjoy some island time! Situated on the border of Ocean Beach and Corneille Estates, you are close to beach access without the restrictions of the Village of Ocean Beach. First floor includes open great room with clean and bright updated kitchen and breakfast bar with seating for 5, dining table for 6 and comfortable living space with sectional couch, TV and double height ceilings. Also on the first floor is one full bathroom, laundry & three guest bedrooms. Retreat to the second floor for your primary suite with ensuite, walk in closet & private deck! Spacious main deck has plenty of lounge seating for everyone to get a spot in the sun, or the shade! Cool off in the private pool after a day in the sun. Of course no beach house is compelte with out an outdoor shower! BBQ, Bikes & Beach Gear included. Less than 650 feet, or a 2 minute walk down to the beach! Only a 7 minute walk into the Village of Ocean Beach for the ferry, shopping, dining & entertainment. Pet friendly! <br> <br> <br> <br> Bedroom Configuration: <br> First Floor - <br> Guest Bedroom 1: Queen <br> Guest Bedroom 2: Twin over Full Bunk Bed <br> Guest Bedroom 3: 2 sets of Twin Bunk Beds (4 Twins) <br> Second Floor - <br> Primary Suite: King <br> <br> Available for Rent 2024: $12,000/week <br> <br> Inquire with Alyssa O'Keefe at 631-988-0819 or alyssa@fisr.com to confirm availability!
  • Kismet, NY 11770
    $11,000
    5 Bedrooms 3 Full Baths
    Single Family For Rent ID# KIS-102r
    Situated steps from the Great South Bay, this home has everything you need to enjoy fun in the sun on Fire Island. Relax on the sunny deck or cool off in the pool all while taking in beautiful views of the bay. Great room with living room, dining area & kitchen opens up to outdoor deck through large sliding doors. Rounding out the first floor are four bedrooms and two full bathrooms; one being a jack-and-jill bathroom accessed between Bedrooms 3 & 4. Private suite located on the second level complete with queen size bed, full bathroom, kitchenette, dining table, remote work setup & deck is accessible via separate entrance. This home is fully stocked with everything you could need for a beach vacation; beach towels, umbrellas, beach chairs, bikes, & wagon. An initial supply of paper products (toilet paper, paper towels, etc.) and propane tank supplied. Take a stroll to the famous Fire Island Lighthouse, approximately 1 mile away. Ferry dock, Dive, the Kismet Inn, market, pizzeria, Kismet Coffee & marina all about a 7 minute walk away. Perfect for your next summer getaway! <br> <br> Bedroom Configuration: <br> Bedroom 1: King Size Bed <br> Bedroom 2: 2 Twins <br> Bedroom 3: King Size Bed <br> Bedroom 4: Queen Size Bed <br> Upstairs Suite: Queen Size Bed
  • Ocean Bay Park, NY
    $11,000
    5 Bedrooms 2 Full Baths 1 Half Bath
    Single Family For Rent ID# obp-10r
    5 BR home has an inverted layout that's perfect for entertaining! With large, open living space upstairs, there are great views of the bay and can hear the ocean as you are above most house tops in the area. This house is large and very spacious, providing you and your family ample room to "spread out". Bedrooms have plenty of space. Lower deck provides a great spot to have a nice morning coffee and listen to the birds. All bedrooms have air conditioning. The full house has wireless internet and Hulu with Live TV in the living room and every bedroom. Large grill provided with propane as well as house amenities (laundry & detergent, cleaning supplies, toilet paper, paper towels, hand soap, dishwasher detergent). Bikes provided with the house for your use. <br> First Floor: <br> Bedroom 1 - 2 bunk beds with full on bottom and twin on top (4 mattresses total) <br> Bedroom 2 - 1 bunk bed with full on bottom and twin on top and one twin bed <br> Bedroom 3 - 1 queen size bed <br> Bedroom 4 - 1 queen size bed <br> 2 Full Baths - one with tub <br> Laundry Room with 2 washers and dryers <br> Deck with seating and private outdoor shower with hot water <br> Second Floor (open floor plan): <br> Large Living Room. Large Kitchen and Dining Room (seats 13). Large French Doors from Dining Room to Deck <br> Master Bedroom w/ queen bed (sleeps 2) <br> Half Bath <br> Large entertaining deck with grill, with French Doors to Dining Room/Kitchen <br> Amenities: Air Conditioning in all bedrooms. Double Stacked Washer/Dryer. Blankets. Hulu with LiveTV in All Bedrooms and the Living Room. Wireless Internet. BBQ Grill and Propane Gas. Fully Stocked Kitchen. Beach Chairs & Umbrella's. Bicycles
  • 1 Spatenga Walk Water Island, NY 11770
    $10,000
    3 Bedrooms 2 Full Baths
    Single Family For Rent ID# WI-1R
    Impeccably renovated from top to bottom, this beachfront residence boasts panoramic Atlantic Ocean views, 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, and a spacious wraparound deck. Located on the eastern end of Fire Island, in an exclusive enclave of Water Island, this one of a kind home offers the utmost privacy, peace, and quiet in a truly spectacular setting. If you're seeking a quiet place to relax, look no further. With lush vegetation and National Seashore Preserve lands to the east and west, you will enjoy the majestic views and natural setting at this special property. The open great room features 3 walls of glass through which to take in the mesmerizing views, a brand new high-end kitchen, vaulted ceilings, and designer furnishings. The luxurious ocean view primary bedroom features a beautifully appointed en-suite bathroom, high ceilings, ample closet space, and direct access to the deck. Enjoy the stunning, never crowded beach directly in front of the home, or walk a short stretch down the sand to the lifeguarded area of Barrett Beach. Also included is private boat transfers from the mainland to the house via the private dock shared by the 4 homes in the community. This incredible retreat is less than 60 miles from Manhattan, 1 mile from the Fire Island Pines, 1.5 miles from Davis Park, and only a 15 minute boat ride across the Great South Bay from Sayville.<BR> <BR>
  • Ocean Beach, NY 11770
    $9,750
    4 Bedrooms 2 Full Baths 1 Half Bath
    Single Family For Rent ID# OB-362R
    Come enjoy life at the beach at this stunning four bedroom, two and a half bathroom home situated on the Ocean Beach - Corneille Estates border. Every room in the house is generously sized. First floor has three spacious bedrooms, one full bathroom & laundry room. Luxury eat in kitchen, living room, powder room and primary suite with private bedroom & show stopping ensuite are on the second floor. Walk out to the second story mahogany deck from the kitchen for easy outdoor entertaining. Stay comfortable with Central A/C throughout home! House is fully equipped with WiFi, Dish TV, Sonos Sound System, BBQ, beach chairs, beach umbrella, bikes & wagon. Discount considered for multiple week rental. <br> <br> Available for weekly rent July & August: $9,750 <br>*June/September weeks renting at $7,500 for the week!* <br> <br> Bedroom Configuration: <br> Second Floor <br> Primary Suite: King <br> First Floor <br> Guest Bedroom 2: 2 Queens <br> Guest Bedroom 3: 1 Queen <br> Guest Bedroom 4: 1 Queen
  • Corneille Estates, NY 11770
    $9,500
    Single Family For Rent ID# CE-50r
    <br> Escape to this updated & comfortable four bedroom, three bathroom home in laid back Corneille Estates with two levels of brand new mahogany decking. Watch the sunsets over the Great South Bay on the second floor deck. Open concept great room with living area, dining area & kitchen with sliders out to the deck. Not one but two private & spacious outdoor showers on both the first level and second level deck! Primary Suite with King size bed is also on the second floor. Downstairs are the three additional bedrooms and a hallway bathroom. Head down to the unrestricted Corneille Estates beach about a 5 minute stroll down the boardwalk. The nearby bustling town of Ocean Beach is only a 7 minute walk away for dining, shopping, entertainment & transportation. Pets considered. Short term stays from Wednesdays-Sundays available. <br> Bedroom Configuration: <br> Upstairs: <br> King with ensuite <br> Downstairs: <br> Queen with ensuite <br> Twin over Full Bunk Bed <br> 2 Twin over Twin Bunk Beds (4 Twins)
Showing 11 - 20 of 63 results| view:  results per page« 1|2|3|4|5|...|last »